◀ All quests
Byte with a magnifying glass
PasqualTeaches · Mission log

Modals of Deduction
with Byte

Must, might, can't, should have, will… How sure are you? Use modals like a detective to talk about the present, the past and the future: certainty, possibility, impossibility, expectation and criticism. B2–C1 C2

Tap any word with a dotted blue line to hear it.

The certainty scale

Modals of deduction say how sure you are, based on the evidence. B2–C1

Byte with a magnifying glass

From 100% sure to 0%

100%
will / mustI'm sure it's true
~80%
should / ought toit's expected
~50%
mayperhaps
~40%
might / coulda weaker perhaps
~30%
may not / might notperhaps not
0%
can't / couldn'tI'm sure it's impossible
0%
won'tI'm sure it isn't

Same evidence, different certainty

  • (I'm sure)
  • (confident assumption)
  • She left at six. She should be there by now. (expected)
  • He may be in a meeting. (perhaps)
  • It might / could be true. (possible)
  • She may not / might not know. (perhaps not)
  • (impossible)
  • That won't be Tom. He's in Paris. (sure it isn't)

Byte's rule: the opposite of must (deduction) is can't, NOT mustn't. Mustn't = prohibition.

Present
must / might / can't + be
must be working
Past
must / might / can't + have + past participle
Future
should, may well, be bound to, be likely to…

Present deduction

Talk about now: states and actions in progress. B2–C1

Byte with a hammer

States: modal + base verb

Subject+must / may / might / could / can't+base verb
  • She must know the answer. She's a doctor.
  • This might be the right road.
  • You can't be serious!

Actions now: modal + be + -ing

Subject+modal+be+verb-ing
  • Listen! They must be having a party.
  • He's not answering. He might be driving.
  • She can't be working. It's Sunday.
FormExampleNotes
PositiveHe must / may / might / could be tired.could = might here (possibility)
Negative (impossible)He can't / couldn't be tired.can't = I'm sure it isn't true. Contractions: can't = cannot, couldn't = could not
Negative (perhaps not)He may not / might not be tired.No contraction for may not; mightn't is rare (British)
QuestionsCould she be lost? Might he be lying? Can it be true?Use could, might (formal) or can. Not may, not must.
Wh- questionsWho can that be? Where could they be?Very common when you are puzzled

Could he be at the gym?

May he be at the gym?

Byte's trick: action verb happening now? Add be + -ing: "He must work hard" (in general) vs "He must be working" (right now).

Past deduction

Look at the evidence now and think about what happened before. B2–C1

Byte with a clipboard

Completed actions

modal+have+past participle
  • The ground is wet. It must have rained.
  • She may have / might have / could have missed the bus.
  • He can't have / couldn't have seen us. It was dark.

Actions in progress

modal+have been+verb-ing
  • His eyes are red. He must have been crying.
  • She might have been sleeping when you called.
  • They can't have been listening.
FormFullSpoken / contracted
PositiveShe must have left.She must've left. /ˈmʌstəv/
PositiveHe might have / may have / could have forgotten.might've, may've, could've
Negative (impossible)She cannot have / could not have done it.can't have, couldn't have
Negative (perhaps not)He may not have / might not have heard.might not've (spoken)
Yes/no questions · · Might she have forgotten?
Wh- questionsWhere can they have gone? Who could have taken it? What might have happened?
Short answersCould she have left? – She might have. / She must have. / She can't have.

He must have gone. (have + past participle)

He must had gone. / He must have went.

Byte's trick: modals never change. After a modal comes have (never has, never had), and after have comes the 3rd column: gone, seen, taken.

Tricky pairs

Same modal, different job. Deduction or obligation? Possibility or criticism? B2–C1

Byte with a magnifying glass

must have vs had to

must have done = deduction (I'm sure it happened).
had to do = past obligation (it was necessary).

  • She must have worked late. Her light was on at 11. (I guess)
  • She had to work late. Her boss told her. (obligation)

can't have vs mustn't have

For "I'm sure it didn't happen", use can't have / couldn't have.

He can't have stolen it. He was with me.

He mustn't have stolen it.

Mustn't = don't do it (prohibition). It has no past form for deduction in standard British English.

could have done: 3 meanings

  • Possibility: She's late. She could have got lost. (maybe she did)
  • Unrealised ability: I could have won, but I fell. (I was able, but I didn't)
  • Criticism: (you didn't, and I'm annoyed)

Also: couldn't have + comparative = maximum: "I couldn't have been happier!"

should have / ought to have

  • Expectation: The parcel should have arrived by now. (it was expected; maybe it has)
  • Regret: I should have studied more. (I didn't)
  • Criticism: You ought to have called. / You shouldn't have shouted.

ought to have = should have, a bit more formal. Negative: oughtn't to have (rare).

Byte's test: can you say "I bet…" or "I'm sure…"? It's deduction → must have. Can you say "it was necessary"? It's obligation → had to.

May, might, could, will

Small words, small differences. Here is how natives choose. B2–C1

Byte thinking

may vs might vs could

  • may: a bit more formal and a bit more certain. "The results may change."
  • might: the most common in speech, a bit less sure. "I might be wrong."
  • could: a possibility (often an idea or option). "It could be the battery."
  • Negatives are different! may not / might not = perhaps not. could not = impossible.

She might not be home. (perhaps not)

She couldn't be home. (impossible)

might have / may have

Both = perhaps it happened. Today they are almost the same.

  • He may have / might have left already.

Careful usage: if we know it didn't happen, use might have (or could have):

You were lucky. You might have been killed!

You may have been killed! (sounds like we don't know)

will / won't: confident assumption

We use will for something we believe is true now, based on habit or knowledge.

  • (doorbell)
  • Don't call now. They'll be having dinner.
  • He won't know the answer. He's new.
  • Past: You'll have heard the news, I suppose.

must vs will

must = I reached this conclusion from evidence.
will = I know it from experience / habit; it's no surprise.

  • Look at her tan! She must have been on holiday.
  • It's 6 pm. Mum'll be home from work.

Future speculation & other ways

Predictions with degrees of certainty, plus adverbs and phrases. B2–C1

Byte flying with a jetpack

Future speculation

100%She's bound to win. / She's sure / certain to win.
~80%It should be easy. / It's likely to rain. / It'll probably rain.
~60%It may well / might well / could well snow. (well = more likely)
~40%It may / might / could snow. / There's a chance that it'll snow.
~20%It probably won't snow. / It's unlikely to snow.
0%It definitely won't snow. / There's no chance it'll snow.

Also: be likely/unlikely that: It's likely that prices will rise. · There's a good / slight chance (that)…

Adverbs: where do they go?

He'll probably come. (after will)

He probably won't come. (before won't)

She's definitely right. (after be)

Possibly / Perhaps / Maybe he's ill. (start)

certainly, definitely, probably: after auxiliary in positive, before it in negative.

Phrases for guessing

  • I bet she's forgotten. (informal, sure)
  • I doubt (that / if) he'll come. (probably not)
  • It looks as if / as though it's going to rain.
  • I reckon they've split up. (informal, = I think)
  • There's no way he did that! (= he can't have)

I doubt he'll come.

I doubt he won't come. (double negative idea)

Tips & tricks: the evidence detective

Ask two questions: How strong is my evidence? When did it happen? B2–C1

Byte with a clipboard
My evidence says…NowNow, in progressPast
Strong: yes!must bemust be doingmust have done
Expectedshould beshould be doingshould have done
Weak: maybemay / might / could bemight be doingmight / may / could have done
Weak: maybe notmay not / might not bemight not be doingmay not / might not have done
Strong: no way!can't / couldn't becan't be doingcan't / couldn't have done
The detective's 3 steps
1. Find a clue. 2. Decide %. 3. Choose the time (now / past).
Sound it out
must've /ˈmʌstəv/, could've /ˈkʊdəv/, should've /ˈʃʊdəv/. People think they hear "of". Write have!
Negative trick
can't = 0% · might not = 30–40% · Never "mustn't" for deduction.

You should've told me.

You should of told me.

Byte's mnemonic: "Must is a yes, can't is a no, might is a maybe, have takes it back in time, so!"

Traps for Spanish speakers

Spanish "debe de", "puede que" and "habrá" make these mistakes very common. B2–C1

Byte with a warning sign

"Debe de estar en casa"

He must be at home.

He must to be at home. / He must of be at home.

"debe de" = must + base verb. No "to", no "of". And "debería estar" (expected) = should be.

"No puede haberlo hecho"

She can't have done it.

She mustn't have done it.

Opposite of must (deduction) = can't. Mustn't = prohibido.

"Puede que esté enfermo"

He may / might / could be ill.

He can be ill.

Can = general possibility ("It can be cold in winter"), not a guess about one situation.

"Debe de haber salido"

She must have left.

She must had left. / She must has left.

Modal + have (always the base form).

"Deberías haberlo dicho"

You should have said it.

You should had said it. / You should have say it.

should + have + past participle.

"Podría haber ganado"

He could have won.

He could has won. / He could won.

Don't forget have, and never "has".

"Habrá llegado ya" (futuro de probabilidad)

She'll have arrived by now. / She must have arrived.

She will arrive already.

Spanish uses the future for guesses; English uses will have / must have.

"Tuvo que ser él"

It must have been him. (deduction)

It had to be him. (= it was necessary / obligation in most contexts)

"Tuvo que" can be both in Spanish. Deduction → must have.

Level up: necessity, irony and reproach

Expressions that make your English sound native. C2

Byte celebrating

needn't have vs didn't need to

  • I needn't have cooked. They'd already eaten. (I did it, but it was unnecessary)
  • I didn't need to cook, so I went out. (it wasn't necessary; usually I didn't)

might as well / may as well

  • The bus has gone. We might as well walk. (there's no better option)
  • You may as well be talking to a wall. (ironic comparison)
  • We might as well have stayed at home. (past: it was a waste)

I might have known / guessed

= It's typical; I'm not surprised (and I'm annoyed).

  • He's late again. I might have known!
  • I might have guessed you'd say that.

"You might have…" (reproach)

  • You might have told me you were coming! (= you should have)
  • You might at least say thank you. (present)

Fixed expressions

  • It can't be helped. = Nothing can be done; accept it.
  • Well might you ask! = That's a very good question (formal, ironic). Also: You may well ask.
  • Be that as it may, … = even so.
  • Try as I might, I couldn't open it. = however hard I tried.

would have: assumptions about the past

  • "Who was that man with Anna?" – "That would have been her brother."
  • She would have been about twenty when she married. (my estimate)
  • Present: That would be Jim's car, I think.

Level up: passive deduction & academic hedging

For essays, reports and the C2 exam. C2

Byte with a clipboard

Passive deduction

modal+have been+past participle
  • My bike's gone. It must have been stolen.
  • The letter can't have been sent. It's still here.
  • The house might have been built in the 1800s.
  • Present: The road must be being repaired. (rare, but correct)

Academic hedging

Writers avoid sounding too sure. They soften claims:

  • The data appear to / seem to show a link.
  • The drug appears to have reduced symptoms. (perfect infinitive)
  • Prices are likely to have risen since then.
  • It would seem / appear that the theory is wrong.
  • It is thought / believed that… · He is thought to have left.
  • This may / could / might suggest that… · This tends to…
  • arguably, presumably, conceivably, in all likelihood
Too strongHedged (academic)
This proves that diet causes the illness.This would seem to suggest that diet may contribute to the illness.
The Romans built this wall.The wall is believed to have been built by the Romans.
Everyone will agree.Most readers are likely to agree.

Byte's C2 trick: stack a hedge: "It would appear that the results may be…". One or two hedges = careful. Five = you sound like you have no opinion!

Practice mission

Pick a mission. Read the clue, then choose the best modal.

Byte with a stopwatch

Next level: write it yourself

Type the answer. First try = 2 points, second try or hint = 1 point.

Byte flying with a jetpack