◀ All quests
Byte, the astronaut bird, waving hello
PasqualTeaches · Mission log

Relative Clauses
with Byte

Who, which, that, whose, where, when, why and what: how to add information about a person, thing or place, join two sentences into one, and avoid the classic Spanish-speaker traps. Then LEVEL UP to C1–C2.

Tap any word with a dotted blue line to hear it.

The relative words

A relative clause gives extra information about a noun. It starts with a relative word. A2–B2

Byte pointing
WordUse it forExample
whopeople (subject or object)
whichthings and animals
thatpeople or things, only in defining clausesThe film that we saw was great.
whosepossession (= his / her / its / their)That's the boy whose dog bit me.
whompeople, object, formalThe man whom she married is Irish.
whereplaces (= in / at which)This is the café where we met.
whentimes (= on / in which)I remember the day when I passed my test.
whyreasons (after the reason)That's the reason why I'm late.
what= the thing(s) that (no noun before it!)What I need is a holiday.

Where does it go?

Straight after the noun it describes:

noun+who / which / that…+rest of clause

The girl who won the race is my cousin.

Subject or object?

Subject: the pronoun does the action.
The man who called me… (he called me)

Object: another subject comes after it.
The man who I called… (I called him)

Byte's trick: who = people, which = things, that = both (but only without commas). whose = "of who", for owners.

Defining vs non-defining

Is the information necessary to know WHICH one? Or is it just extra? Commas tell you.

Byte with a magnifier

Defining (essential)

Tells us which person or thing. Without it, the sentence is incomplete.


(only the ones who studied passed)

  • ✓ no commas
  • ✓ that is possible
  • ✓ object pronoun can be omitted

Non-defining (extra)

Adds extra info about something we already know. You can delete it.


(all of them studied and all passed)

  • ✓ commas (or a pause when speaking)
  • ✗ never "that"
  • ✗ never omit the pronoun

No "that" with commas

My sister, who lives in Leeds, is a nurse.

My sister, that lives in Leeds, is a nurse.

No omission with commas

Paris, which I visited last year, is beautiful.

Paris, I visited last year, is beautiful.

Typical non-defining nouns

Names, unique things, "my mother", "my house": we already know who/which, so the clause is extra → commas.

Shakespeare, who was born in 1564, wrote 39 plays. · My dad, who is a chef, cooks every day.

The comma test: cover the clause with your finger. Do you still know exactly who or what? Yes → it's extra → commas, no "that". No → it's essential → no commas.

Leave it out? Prepositions?

In defining clauses we often drop the pronoun. And prepositions usually go at the end.

Byte with a hammer

You CAN omit it: object

If a new subject comes after the pronoun, it's an object → you can drop it.

noun+(who/which/that)+subject + verb

The book (that) I'm reading is great.
The people (who) we met were kind.

You CAN'T omit it: subject

If a verb comes straight after the pronoun, it's the subject → keep it.

noun+who/which/that+verb

The man who lives here is a doctor.

The man lives here is a doctor.

Prepositions in relative clauses

StyleExample
Everyday (preposition at the end)The man (who / that) I spoke to was friendly.
Everyday, thingsThe house (which / that) she lives in is old.
Formal (preposition first)The man to whom I spoke was friendly.
Formal, thingsThe house in which she lives is old.

the man to whom I spoke · the house in which she lives

the man to who I spoke · the house in that she lives

After a preposition use only whom (people) or which (things). Never who or that.

Byte's trick: look right after the pronoun. Verb? → keep it. Person/thing + verb? → you may drop it. And remember: speaking = preposition at the end; formal writing = preposition + whom/which.

Whose, where, what & which

Four special cases that students mix up.

Byte with a clipboard

whose: people AND things

whose + noun = his/her/its/their + noun.

I have a friend whose brother is famous. (= her brother)
It's a city whose streets are very narrow. (= its streets)

the girl whose phone was stolen

the girl who her phone was stolen

where vs which

where = in/at which → the clause is complete without a preposition or object.

the town where I live (I live there)
the town which I visited (I visited it)
the town which I live in = the town in which I live

the town which I visited

the town where I visited

what = the thing(s) that

No noun before it. It includes the noun.

What you said was true. · I know what you want.

Everything that he said was true.

Everything what he said was true.

Sentence which

, which can refer to the whole idea before it. Always a comma, never that or what.

He passed all his exams, which surprised everyone.
It rained all week, which was a pity.

She was late, which made me angry.

She was late, what made me angry.

when and why

the year when I was born · the moment (when / that) I saw her · the reason (why / that) he left. In defining clauses, when and why can be replaced by that or omitted.

Join two sentences, step by step

The best way to master relative clauses: make two sentences into one.

Byte flying with a jetpack

4 steps

SentencesI met a girl. She speaks five languages.
1. Find the repeated person/thinga girl = she
2. Replace it with a relative wordshe → who (person, subject)
3. Put the clause right after the nounI met a girl who speaks five languages.
4. Delete the old pronoun!✗ a girl who she speaks…

The car is new. I drive it.
→ The car (that) I drive is new.

That's Ana. Her dad is a pilot.
→ That's Ana, whose dad is a pilot.

This is the hotel. We stayed there.
→ This is the hotel where we stayed.

Tips & tricks

The "that" shortcut: no commas? that works for people and things. When in doubt in a defining clause, use that, but never after a comma or a preposition.

One pronoun only: the relative word REPLACES he, she, it, them. If you see both, delete one!

where test: can you say "there"? → where. Can you say "it"? → which.

after superlatives & all/everything/nothing: prefer that or nothing: the best film (that) I've seen, all (that) I want.

Traps for Spanish speakers

Spanish uses que for almost everything. English is pickier.

Byte with a warning sign

1. "which" for people

the man who / that called

the man which called

which = things only.

2. Pronoun repeated

the book that is on the table

the book that it is on the table

"that" is already the subject. No "it".

3. Subject repeated

the people who live here

the people who they live here

Spanish "que viven" has no "ellos"; English neither.

4. Object repeated

the film that I saw

the film that I saw it

"que vi" not "que lo vi".

5. "what" instead of that/which

the thing that I like · all that I have

the thing what I like · all what I have

"lo que" = what, but only if there's NO noun before it.

6. "what" for a whole sentence

He lied, which was stupid.

He lied, what was stupid.

", lo cual / lo que" after a sentence = , which.

7. "in which" vs "where" vs "in where"

the house where I grew up / in which I grew up

the house in where I grew up · the house where I grew up in

where already contains the preposition.

8. "who" for "whose"

the man whose car was stolen

the man who his car was stolen

"cuyo / a quien le robaron" = whose.

9. "that" after a comma

Madrid, which is the capital, …

Madrid, that is the capital, …

10. Preposition at the start of the clause

the girl (who) I went out with

the girl with who I went out

Formal: with whom. Normal: preposition at the end.

Reduced clauses, whom & quantifiers

Shorter, more formal and more elegant relative clauses. C1–C2

Byte with a hammer

-ing (active)

The man who is sitting there is my boss.
Anyone wanting a ticket should call. (= who wants)

Works for continuous and simple active meaning.

-ed / past participle (passive)

The bridge which was built in 1890 is closed.
Goods made in China are cheap.

to-infinitive

After the first, the last, the only, the next + superlatives:

She was the first person to arrive.
He's the only one to have passed.
There's nothing to do.

The woman sitting next to me was rude.

The woman sat next to me was rude. (in formal writing)

whom & preposition fronting

whom = object form of who. Formal; obligatory after a preposition.

The candidate whom we interviewed…
The colleague with whom I share an office…
The extent to which this matters…

Some phrasal verbs can't be split: the child (whom) she looks after, ✗ after whom she looks.

Quantifier + of whom / of which

Non-defining only, after a comma.

I have two brothers, both of whom are doctors.
She wrote ten novels, most of which were bestsellers.
I tried two keys, neither of which worked.
He gave us advice, none of which was useful.

…students, many of whom live abroad

…students, many of them live abroad, (comma splice) / many of who

Also formal: the … of which / whose

a house the roof of which needs repairing = a house whose roof needs repairing.

Whereby, whoever & nominal clauses

Exam-level relatives for academic and formal English. C1–C2

Byte with a megaphone

whereby · wherein

whereby = by which, through which (systems, methods, agreements).
They signed a deal whereby profits are shared equally.

wherein = in which (very formal, legal).
The contract, wherein the terms are set out, …

whoever · whatever · whichever

= any person / thing that; it doesn't matter who/what.

Whoever finishes first wins.
Take whatever you need.
Choose whichever option suits you. (from a limited set)
Sit wherever you like. Come whenever you want.

Nominal relative clauses

The clause works as a noun (subject, object or complement). With what, whatever, whoever, where, how.

What surprised me was his attitude. (subject)
That's exactly what I meant. (complement)
This is where it all began. · I love how you explain it.

This is how I do it. / This is the way I do it.

This is the way how I do it.

Cleft sentences

Focus one element with It is/was … who/that …:

Tom broke the window. → It was Tom who broke the window (not Sam).
It was in 2010 that we met.

Wh-cleft: What I need is a rest. · All I did was ask.

It was my keys that I lost.

It was my keys what I lost.

Register & style notes

  • • that is preferred after all, everything, nothing, something, the only, the best: Nothing that he said made sense.
  • • who replaces whom in speech (the man who I saw); whom sounds formal or old-fashioned.
  • • Non-defining clauses are more typical of writing; in speech we often use two sentences.
  • • those who: Those who arrive late won't be admitted. (= people who)

Byte's C2 trick: to sound formal, reduce (-ing / -ed / to), front the preposition (in which, to whom) and use quantifiers (most of whom).

Practice mission

Pick a mission and choose the right answer.

Byte with a stopwatch

Next level: write it yourself

Type the answer. First try = 2 points, second try or hint = 1 point.

Byte flying with a jetpack