◀ All quests
Byte, the astronaut bird, waving hello
PasqualTeaches · Mission log

For and Against
Quest with Byte

The discursive essay: look at both sides of a debate fairly, weigh them up, and only give a careful opinion at the very end. Structures, model essays, language banks, games and a Writing Lab.

Tap any word with a dotted blue line to hear it.

What is a for and against essay?

A formal essay that presents both sides of an issue in a balanced, neutral way. The writer is like a judge, not a lawyer.

Byte with a magnifying glass

Opinion essay vs for and against

  • Opinion essay: your opinion is in the introduction and in every paragraph. You defend one side (lawyer).
  • For and against: the introduction and the body are neutral. You present both sides with equal weight. Your opinion (if any) appears only in the conclusion, and it is cautious (judge).

Typical exam tasks

  • EOI (B1–C1): "Write an essay discussing the advantages and disadvantages of…", "Discuss the pros and cons of…", "Some people think… others believe… Discuss both views."
  • Cambridge C1 Advanced: you get three points in notes; write about two and explain which is more important (220–260 words).
  • B2 First: the essay is usually opinion-based, but you must still deal with the other side.

Where does the writer's voice appear? chart

OPINION
ESSAY
P1Thesis: my view
P2Reason 1
P3Reason 2
P4Other side + refute
P5My view again
FOR AND
AGAINST
P1Present the debate
P2Arguments for
P3Arguments against
P4Weigh up + cautious view

Green bar = how neutral the paragraph is. Yellow = the writer's opinion · green = neutral · lilac = mixed.

Byte's trick: Read the question. "Do you agree?" → opinion essay. "Discuss the advantages and disadvantages" / "Discuss both sides" → for and against. Wrong type = low Content mark.

Two possible structures

Choose one before you write. Both need 4–5 paragraphs and a balanced number of points.

Byte with a hammer

A · Block structure B1–B2

All the pros, then all the cons. Easy and clear.

P1
Intro
Hook + present the issue neutrally. Say there are two sides. No opinion.
P2
For
Topic sentence + 2–3 arguments for, each with a reason or example.
P3
Against
Topic sentence + 2–3 arguments against, with reasons or examples.
P4
End
Sum up both sides + a balanced or cautious opinion.

B · Point-by-point B2–C1

Each body paragraph is one topic: argument + counter-argument. More mature.

P1
Intro
Present the issue and the aspects you will discuss.
P2
Point 1
Aspect 1 (e.g. cost): argument for → counter-argument.
P3
Point 2
Aspect 2 (e.g. health): argument for → counter-argument.
P4
Point 3
(Optional) Aspect 3 → for and against.
P5
End
Weigh up: which side is stronger, and why.

Block: example topic sentences

P2 There are several advantages to working from home.

P3 However, working from home also has a number of drawbacks.

Point-by-point: example

P2 In terms of productivity, supporters claim that remote workers achieve more. Conversely, critics point out that…

P3 As far as social life is concerned, …

Byte's trick: Balance = similar length for both sides. If the "for" paragraph has 3 ideas and the "against" paragraph has 1, the essay is not balanced. Put the side you agree with second, just before the conclusion.

Introductions that stay neutral

Catch the reader's attention, present the debate, and do not take sides. Four ways to start:

Byte with a megaphone

1 · General statement

"In recent years, the number of people working from home has risen dramatically. While some see this as progress, others are concerned about its effects."

2 · Rhetorical question

"Should mobile phones be banned in schools? This question has divided parents and teachers for years, and there are convincing arguments on both sides."

3 · Quotation

"As the saying goes, 'Travel broadens the mind.' But does tourism always benefit the places people visit? The issue is more complex than it seems."

4 · Statistic / fact

"According to recent figures, almost half of all teenagers spend over four hours a day online. This has sparked a heated debate about the role of the internet in young people's lives."

Last sentence: announce the debate

  • There are strong arguments on both sides.
  • This essay will examine both sides of the issue.
  • The issue has both advantages and disadvantages.
  • Opinions on this matter are deeply divided.

✓ / ✗

Opinions on banning cars from city centres are divided.

I think banning cars is a great idea and I will explain why.

Fast fashion has become a global phenomenon.

Nowadays, a lot of people buy a lot of clothes.

Byte's trick: Hook + issue + "two sides" sentence = 3 sentences, about 40 words. Never copy the question: paraphrase it.

Model essay · B2 (block structure)

An EOI-style task. Notice that the writer only gives an opinion in the last paragraph.

Byte with a clipboard

The task

Write an essay discussing the advantages and disadvantages of teenagers having a part-time job while they are still at school. (140–190 words)

topic sentencelinkerimpersonal / cautious languagecounter-argument

Should students work while they study?

P1 · INTRODUCTIONIn Britain, many teenagers combine their studies with a part-time job, but in Spain this is far less common.1 Should students work while they are still at school, or should they concentrate entirely on their studies?2 There are strong arguments on both sides.3

P2 · ARGUMENTS FOROn the one hand, a part-time job has clear advantages.4 Firstly, it teaches young people the value of money, since they have to earn what they spend. Moreover, it is often claimed that working develops responsibility and gives students useful experience for their CV.5

P3 · ARGUMENTS AGAINSTOn the other hand, critics maintain that a job can harm students' academic results.6 Teenagers who work in the evenings may be too tired to study, and their marks could suffer as a result. Furthermore, they may have less time for friends, sport and rest.

P4 · CONCLUSIONIn conclusion, a part-time job has both benefits and drawbacks.7 On balance, I believe it can be a positive experience, provided that students work only a few hours a week and their studies remain the priority.8

Approx. 175 words · 4 paragraphs · 0 contractions

  1. Hook: a general statement / contrast, not "Nowadays…".
  2. A rhetorical question presents the two sides of the debate.
  3. Neutral announcement. No opinion in the introduction.
  4. Topic sentence: the reader knows this paragraph is about advantages.
  5. Impersonal language: the writer reports what others say.
  6. The other side gets the same space: two arguments each.
  7. Summary of both sides first…
  8. …then a cautious opinion with a condition ("provided that").

Model essay · C1 Advanced

Choose two of the three points, discuss each fairly, then say which is more important and why.

Byte with a clipboard

The task (220–260 words)

Your class has attended a panel discussion on what governments could do to reduce traffic in city centres. Write an essay discussing two of the methods in your notes. You should explain which method is more important, giving reasons in support of your answer.

Notes: congestion charges · better public transport · more cycle lanes

Opinions expressed: "Driving is a basic right." · "Buses are too slow." · "Cities belong to people, not cars."

topic sentencelinkerimpersonal / hedgingcounter-argument / concession

P1 · INTRODUCTIONFew would dispute that traffic congestion has become one of the most pressing problems facing modern cities.1 Not only does it waste time, but it also damages public health. Of the various measures proposed, congestion charges and improved public transport are arguably the most frequently discussed.2

P2 · METHOD 1Proponents of congestion charges argue that making drivers pay to enter the centre is the quickest way to reduce traffic. London and Stockholm, where such schemes have cut congestion significantly, are often cited as evidence.3 Critics, however, maintain that charges penalise those on lower incomes, who may have no alternative but to drive. Admittedly, the revenue can be reinvested, but this does little to address the question of fairness.4

P3 · METHOD 2Improving public transport, by contrast, tackles the root of the problem rather than its symptoms.5 If buses and trams are frequent, reliable and affordable, many people will leave their cars at home voluntarily. Granted, such investment is costly and its benefits take years to appear. Nevertheless, it offers a long-term solution that does not exclude anyone.6

P4 · WHICH IS MORE IMPORTANT?Weighing up both options, it seems to me that better public transport is the more important measure, since charging drivers without offering a genuine alternative is likely to prove both unpopular and unjust.7 Ideally, though, the two approaches should go hand in hand, with revenue from charges funding cleaner, faster services.8

Approx. 235 words · 4 paragraphs · 0 contractions

  1. Strong, impersonal hook ("Few would dispute that…").
  2. The intro names the two methods chosen and uses hedging (arguably).
  3. Argument + evidence (real examples), reported impersonally.
  4. Counter-argument and a concession (Admittedly…, but…) in the same paragraph: point-by-point balance.
  5. "By contrast" links the two methods: cohesion across paragraphs.
  6. Granted… Nevertheless…: concede a weakness, then evaluate.
  7. The task asks which is more important: answer it clearly, with a reason.
  8. A nuanced final thought: the methods can combine. Not a new argument, a synthesis.

Byte's trick: You may use the "opinions expressed" in your own words, but you don't have to. Never copy them in quotation marks.

Language bank: arguments and counter-arguments

Report what other people think. The body of the essay is not "I think" but "Some argue…".

Byte with a clipboard

Introducing arguments FOR

  • Proponents / Supporters of X argue that…
  • One major advantage of X is that…
  • The main argument in favour of X is that…
  • Those in favour of X point out that…
  • X is believed to + verb… (is believed to reduce stress)
  • A further point is that…

Introducing arguments AGAINST

  • Critics / Opponents maintain that…
  • One major drawback of X is that…
  • The main argument against X is that…
  • Those opposed to X claim that…
  • X is said to + verb… (is said to cause anxiety)
  • Another objection is that…

Switching sides

  • On the one hand, … On the other hand, …
  • Conversely, … (the opposite is true)
  • In contrast / By contrast, …
  • However, not everyone agrees.
  • Whereas some see X as a benefit, others…

Conceding and answering

  • Admittedly, X. Nevertheless, Y.
  • It is true that X; however, Y.
  • Although X, Y.
  • While it may be true that X, Y.
  • X. Even so, Y.

Byte's trick: Every argument needs support: a reason (because / since), an example (for instance) or a consequence (as a result). A list of bare ideas is not an argument.

Balance, register and impersonal language

A neutral tone makes you sound fair and reliable. Use impersonal structures instead of "I" and "people".

Byte holding a sign
StructureExample
It is often claimed / argued / said that…It is often claimed that exams cause too much stress.
There are those who…There are those who believe homework is unnecessary.
It is widely believed that…It is widely believed that sugar is addictive.
X is thought / considered to be…Remote work is considered to be more flexible.
Many / Some people feel that…Many parents feel that screens harm sleep.
It could be argued that…It could be argued that tourism creates jobs.
Passive with reporting verbsUniforms are said to reduce bullying.

Biased → neutral

Everybody knows that fast food is terrible.

It is widely believed that fast food is unhealthy.

Only stupid people think zoos are good.

There are those who argue that zoos protect endangered species.

Obviously, cars should be banned.

Some argue that cars should be banned from city centres.

Formal register

It does not seem fair.

It doesn't seem fair.

a great deal of / many

a lot of / loads of

children / teenagers

kids

extremely / highly

super / really really

No contractions, no exclamation marks, no "stuff", no "you know".

Byte's trick: Avoid words that judge in the body: obviously, clearly, ridiculous, everyone knows, of course. They tell the examiner you have already chosen a side.

Linkers for discursive essays

Grouped by function. Watch the punctuation: it is part of the grammar.

Byte with a hammer
FunctionLinkersPunctuation
Two sidesOn the one hand… On the other hand…Start of sentence + comma: On the other hand, …
Contrast (new sentence)However · Nevertheless · Nonetheless · Conversely · In contrast · By contrast · Even soX. However, Y. / X; however, Y.
Contrast (same sentence)although · even though · while · whereasAlthough X, Y. / X, whereas Y.
Contrast + noundespite · in spite ofDespite the cost, … / Despite being expensive, …
ConcessionAdmittedly · It is true that · Granted · Of courseAdmittedly, X. Nevertheless, Y.
AddingFirstly · Moreover · Furthermore · In addition · What is more · BesidesStart + comma: Moreover, …
ExampleFor example · For instance · such as · a case in point is…sports, such as football.
ResultAs a result · Consequently · Therefore · thusAs a result, …
Conditionprovided that · as long as · unless…provided that it is controlled.
ConclusionIn conclusion · To sum up · All things considered · On balance · Weighing up both sidesStart + comma

✓ / ✗

Cars are fast. However, they pollute.

Cars are fast, however they pollute.

Despite the cost, it is worth it.

Despite of the cost, it is worth it.

Although it is cheap, it is slow.

Although it is cheap, but it is slow.

Byte's trick: Conversely = the opposite situation is true (Cities offer jobs. Conversely, villages offer peace.). On the other hand always needs an "on the one hand" idea before it, even if you don't write those words.

The balanced conclusion

Summarise both sides, weigh them up, and give a cautious opinion. No new arguments.

Byte relaxing
Signal+both sides in one sentence+weighing up+cautious view / condition

Weighing up

  • On balance, the advantages seem to outweigh the disadvantages.
  • All things considered, it is clear that the issue is complex.
  • Weighing up both sides, the risks appear greater than the benefits.
  • The arguments against are more convincing because…

Cautious opinion

  • It seems to me that…
  • I would argue that…
  • In my view, the best solution may be a compromise.
  • …provided that / as long as …
  • Perhaps the answer lies somewhere in between.

Neutral end

To sum up, homework has both benefits and drawbacks. The key may be to set less of it, but of higher quality.

Leaning end

On balance, I believe the advantages of homework outweigh the disadvantages, provided that it does not take up all of students' free time.

Open end

All things considered, it is up to each school to find the right balance. Perhaps the real question is not how much homework, but what kind.

On balance, the arguments in favour seem stronger.

In conclusion, I totally hate homework and it should be banned forever!

Byte's trick: Your conclusion must match your body. If both sides looked equal, don't suddenly say "it is clearly terrible". Use seem, appear, may to sound careful.

How to plan in 5 minutes

Five minutes of planning saves twenty of rewriting.

Byte with a stopwatch
1
1 min
Read the task twice. Underline the topic, the type ("discuss advantages and disadvantages") and the word count. C1: which two notes?
2
1 min
Brainstorm a T-chart: pros on the left, cons on the right. Aim for 3 + 3.
3
1 min
Choose the best 2 + 2 (each with a reason or example). Choose block or point-by-point.
4
1 min
Hook + final view: pick an intro technique and decide your cautious opinion now.
5
1 min
Linkers: write 5–6 linkers next to your plan so you remember to use them.

A filled-in plan

Topic: Should school uniforms be compulsory? (block, B2)

  • P1 Rhetorical question: "Should students be free to choose…?" → opinions divided.
  • P2 For 1. equality: no pressure about brands (example: cheaper for families) · 2. sense of belonging / identity.
  • P3 Against 1. limits self-expression (teenagers' identity) · 2. some uniforms are expensive / uncomfortable.
  • P4 On balance: benefits > drawbacks, provided that uniforms are cheap and comfortable.
  • Linkers: On the one hand · Moreover · For instance · On the other hand · Furthermore · On balance

Byte's trick: Save 5 minutes at the end to check: contractions? one side longer? opinion too early? spelling of linkers?

Traps for Spanish speakers

The mistakes examiners see again and again. ✓ / ✗ with the reason.

Byte with a warning sign

1 · "In the other hand"

On the other hand, it is expensive.

In the other hand, it is expensive.

"Por otro lado" → on, not "in".

2 · "By one hand"

On the one hand, …

By one hand, … / In one hand, …

Always on the one hand, with the.

3 · Opinion too early

Opinions on this issue are deeply divided.

In my opinion, uniforms are a bad idea.

In a for and against essay, your view waits until the conclusion.

4 · One-sided body

P2: 2 pros · P3: 2 cons

P2: 4 pros · P3: "But it is a bit expensive."

Both sides need similar space and support.

5 · "Nowadays" opener

Over the last decade, online shopping has grown enormously.

Nowadays, a lot of people buy on the internet.

"Hoy en día…" is the most overused start. Use a fact, a question or a precise time phrase.

6 · "A lot of people think"

It is widely believed that… / Many experts argue that…

A lot of people think that…

Too informal and vague. Be impersonal or specific.

7 · "The people" / "the society"

People believe that society is changing.

The people believe that the society is changing.

General plural and abstract nouns: no "the".

8 · "In conclusion" + new idea

In conclusion, both sides have valid points.

In conclusion, another problem is pollution.

No new arguments in the conclusion.

9 · "Despite of" / "although… but"

Despite the price, … / Although it is cheap, it is slow.

Despite of the price, … / Although it is cheap, but it is slow.

"A pesar de" → despite (no "of"). Although never with but.

10 · "Discuss" + about

This essay will discuss the advantages.

This essay will discuss about the advantages.

"Discutir sobre" → discuss + object (no "about").

Concession and hedging

C1–C2 writers accept the other side's strength before answering it, and never sound more certain than the evidence allows.

Byte flying with a jetpack

Concession structures

  • Much as I sympathise with this view, it overlooks…
  • While it is true that X, it does not follow that Y.
  • Granted, X. That said, Y.
  • However convincing this may seem, …
  • Convenient though it may be, online learning… (adj. + though/as)
  • For all its advantages, tourism…
  • Be that as it may, …
  • Valid as this point is, …

Hedging (sounding careful)

  • arguably, to some extent, to a certain degree
  • It would seem / would appear that…
  • This may well lead to…
  • X tends to + verb
  • in many cases, in most instances, by and large
  • It is by no means certain that…

Social media may well contribute to anxiety among teenagers.

Social media destroys all teenagers' mental health.

Evaluating evidence

  • There is little evidence to suggest that…
  • Research appears to indicate that…
  • This claim does not stand up to scrutiny.
  • The evidence is far from conclusive.
  • This argument carries considerable weight.
  • …is often cited as evidence of…

Fronting and inversion for emphasis

  • Not only does it save money, but it also…
  • Only by investing in education can we…
  • What critics fail to consider is that… (cleft)
  • Less convincing is the claim that…

Cohesion and avoiding false balance

Top-band essays link ideas invisibly and weigh arguments honestly: balanced does not mean equal.

Byte thinking

Sophisticated cohesion

  • the former / the latter: Charges and public transport both help, but the latter is fairer.
  • This / Such + summary noun: This approach… Such measures… This trend…
  • Nominalisation: prices rise → the rise in prices; people oppose it → public opposition.
  • Paragraph bridges: Persuasive as these arguments are, there is another side to the debate.
  • Fewer obvious linkers: vary with Yet, Even so, In the same vein, Equally.

Avoiding false balance

  • Don't invent a weak "other side" just for symmetry, or treat a fringe view as equal to strong evidence.
  • Weigh the arguments: The first objection is minor; the second is more serious.
  • Rank them: The most compelling argument…, A weaker, though popular, claim…
  • Let the conclusion follow the weight of the evidence, not a 50/50 split.

While a few dispute the link, the overwhelming scientific consensus is that smoking causes cancer.

Some say smoking causes cancer; others say it does not. Both views are equally valid.

Register: C2 polish

This proposal has merit, yet it raises serious practical concerns.

This is a good idea but there are some problems.

The benefits are unlikely to materialise in the short term.

We will not see the good things soon.

C1 Advanced checklist

  • Exactly two of the three notes, clearly named.
  • Each method: argument and limitation.
  • A clear answer to "which is more important", with a reason.
  • 220–260 words, 4–5 paragraphs, formal register.

Byte's trick: The examiner rewards evaluation, not lists. After every argument ask: "How strong is this? For whom? Under what conditions?"

Practice mission

Pick a mission. Read the explanation after each answer.

Byte with a stopwatch

Next level: write it yourself

Cadet: sort the arguments · Pilot: choose the linker · Commander: rewrite a biased sentence as neutral. First try = 2 points, second try or hint = 1 point.

Byte flying with a jetpack

Writing Lab

Choose your level, get a random exam task and write your for and against essay. Check it automatically, assess yourself, or ask Claude to correct it.

Byte with a phone

Have a Claude account? Open this quest on claude.ai to get AI correction →